Active investment management’s weekly magazine for fee-based advisors

With the calendar moving from October to November, the U.S. equity market has entered its “Best Six Months,” a typically bullish seasonal period.

The “Best Six Months” tendency was first published by Yale Hirsch, founder of the Stock Trader’s Almanac, in 1986. The concept behind the “Best Six Months” is simple. Hirsch’s research suggests that over the last several decades the market has made a massive portion of its gains between November and April. And during the remaining six months, it has generally struggled to make headway. Since this market seasonality tendency was first discovered, the edge has persisted, with the “Best Six Months” continuing to outperform the “Worst Six Months.”

Additionally, the market just shifted into the third year of the presidential cycle. At Quantifiable Edges, I measure the presidential cycle years from November–October rather than January–December. That allows the cycle years to better match up with the actual elections, which take place in early November. And while elections are always during the first week of November, I always start measurement of the cycle year on November 1. This makes for easy evaluation when combining it with the “Best Six Months” cycles. In general, the third year of the presidential cycle has been a strong one.

When the “Best Six Months” and the third year of the presidential cycle have been active at the same time, the results since 1960 have been outstanding. In Table 1, each instance of the two tendencies occurring at the same time has been analyzed. In each case, the analysis shows how an investor would have fared buying a proxy for the S&P 500 at the close on Oct. 31 and selling the investment at the close on April 30.

TABLE 1: S&P 500 TRADING PERFORMANCE NOVEMBER–APRIL

In the third year of the presidential cycle (1960–2017)

Note: Uses assumption of $100,000 invested. The S&P 500 Index (SPX) cannot be directly purchased, and the analysis assumes the use of investment vehicles that track the Index.

Source: Quantifiable Edges

 

All 14 instances since 1960 have shown gains. Of course, there have been drawdowns along the way. The 1974–1975 period saw SPX pull back 13.2% from its October closing price before rebounding and finishing April 18.1% above the October closing price. And in 2002–2003 there was a 10.9% drawdown from the October close before finishing April 3.5% above it. But overall, the statistics have been incredibly lopsided. The average six-month period saw a net gain of 15.5%. The average run-up (from the October close) was 17.7% and the average drawdown just 3.1%. Long-term market seasonality does not get any better. Traders may want to keep this in mind when establishing their current market bias.

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of Proactive Advisor Magazine. These opinions are presented for educational purposes only.

Rob Hanna is president of Hanna Capital Management LLC and founded Quantifiable Edges in 2008. Mr. Hanna uses historical analysis to assess current market action and odds, focusing on price action, volume, breadth, sentiment, seasonality, liquidity flows, and more to conduct his research. A Boston College alum, Mr. Hanna lives and works in Massachusetts. quantifiableedges.com

Manage investment risk better than ever.
Get started – It’s free

Recent Posts:

Active management in plain English

An advisor's perspective. he word “active” certainly has a much more positive connotation than its counterpart, “passive.” But when it comes to investment management, we in the financial-services arena use...

Are we back to the ‘old’ new normal?

hile the phrase “new normal” has been around for some time, the now-retired Bill Gross, then still heading PIMCO, is generally credited for popularizing it in the context of the 2007–2009 financial crisis...

Principles for developing a niche target segment

Larry Welder • San Antonio, TX Granite Financial Solutions LLC • Ameritas Investment Corp.ur firm has a wide range of clients, but we also have developed in-depth knowledge within a specific niche target...